"The Tsuranga Conundrum" is an example of the mid-season Doctor Who
story that won't top any polls or feature in many nostalgic memories.
However, for the first time ever, Chris Chibnall has constructed a
satisfying plot – the fact that the two crises cancel each other out is
actually effective. There is some good world-building going on, with a
good sense being had of the 67th century. We also have a pregnant man
which starts off (as is usual) as a joke, but develops into something
deeper. There is a refreshing lack of predictability about its
progression, which, together with the frenetic pace make this a story
that is leaves the viewer exhilarated by the ride, but not finding
multiple flaws to pick at, later.
Of course, "The Tsuranga Conundrum" is a base-under-siege story, but the
key factor that separates it from the herd are the characters. The
leader is, at some points opposed to the Doctor, but for the best
reasons. Brett Goldstein, primarily a comic actor, is very effective as
Astos and Lois Chimimba puts in good work as Mabli. Suzanne Packer
radiates authority as Eve Cicero and future national treasure Ben Bailey
Smith is a natural as her brother – although Smith has ample experience
of having an illustrious older sister! Jack Shalloo's Yoss, is
surprisingly touching. Graham and Ryan's relationship is very well
served by the script, with Yoss's pregnancy acting as a catalyst for
their understanding of themselves. Sadly, Yas is underused, with the
character mostly feeding questions to the Doctor and listing 21st
century equivalents to the 67th Century gizmos she encounters. Jodie
Whittaker is already making playing the Doctor as natural to her as
breathing. There is a critical scene that shows what a difference the
Doctor being female can be. Astos rebukes the Doctor for being selfish,
for wanting to reroute the Tsuranga, and the Doctor agrees, which is a
scene which works a lot better when the testosterone is removed.
Jennifer Perrott is a good match for the material, giving the story the
sense of urgency it requires. There is only one major location, but the
imaginative design makes the story always interesting to watch. The
monster of the week is the adorable Pting and, if there's one shot which
truly makes the story, it's the look of joy on its face when it is
finally sated.
"The Tsuranga Conundrum" may not be the most memorable story, but it
does show that, perhaps Chibnall does have it in him to run the
programme we love so much.
NEXT: "Demons of the Punjab"
Monday, 12 November 2018
"The Tsuranga Conundrum"
Labels:
Chris Chibnall,
Graham,
Jennifer Perrott,
Nikki Wilson,
Ryan,
Whittaker,
Yasmin
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment