Dragonfire concludes Sylvester McCoy’s first season in style. Again, the basic premise displays a degree of vagueness- Kane is imprisoned with the key to his salvation in (what looks like) easy reach and takes 3000 years to find it, never knowing that his planet has been destroyed in a supernova- despite the fact that he has constructed the interstellar version of an airport terminal on his planet of imprisonment. However, the script contains some wonderful dialogue and some good characters. The actual plot is the hunt for a semi-mythical dragon, which is simple enough for any child to enjoy, but contains such great scenes as the Doctor finding a surprisingly erudite guard (the philosophical conversation that follows, despite some slightly misunderstood terminology, actually makes sense). The names of the characters are taken from figures in film theory (ones who knew what they were talking about) directors (Pudovkin, named after the director of the hugely influential Mother) and films (Kane, named after a character in Buck Rogers in the 25th Century. Haha). In addition, Briggs creates a dragon quest with ‘singing trees’ and ‘ice gardens’. In many ways, this is a throwback to the Doctor journeying into the unknown that we had in the Hartnell era, which is very welcome.
Chris Clough directs well, but the all-studio realisation of the story does make the settings look a bit too artificial, but there is some clever design work here, such as the realisation of the ‘singing trees’. The scenes in the milk bar actually come off rather well, despite being a low-rent version of the Mos Eisley Cantina from Star Wars. The costumes work very well, with the white Pickelhauben worn by Kane’s officers being a nice touch. The special effects are quite good, from the well-realised dragon to the outstanding shot of Kane melting, influenced by and nearly as good as the scene in Raiders of the Lost Ark (incidentally, the only scene in anything that has genuinely given me nightmares). The actual failures of the visualisation are very few- the ‘literal’ cliffhanger to part one can be seen as postmodern (as there are perfectly good cliffhanger moments preceding it) but just comes off as silly. The model for the planet Svartos is nicely designed and filmed, but if Svartos is an Earth-sized planet, the Iceworld complex looks the size of Africa. Surely, a continent-sized craft taking off from a planet would destroy it? However, the production works well, although the fact that Dominic Glynn is doing the music no doubt contributes to this.
The performances are never less than good. Tony Selby makes a very welcome return as Glitz and Patricia Quinn is excellent as Belazs. However, Edward Peel’s Kane is outstanding, making the character very memorable (in a completely different way to Don Henderson’s equally impressive Gavrok in the previous story). This is also the story where we say goodbye to Mel. When she first appeared, I had never seen a companion so annoying. It has to be said, however, that she improved dramatically in her last two stories and she is given a cracking leaving scene. We also say hello to Sophie Aldred as Ace. Aldred is not the best actress in the world, but she truly inhabits the character making Ace instantly memorable- although the attempts to colloquialise her dialogue have mixed results, sometimes creative and amusing, sometimes embarrassing. Sylvester McCoy is in complete command of his character, even making his comic sliding (which no-one else does!) work.
Dragonfire is flawed, but contains much that is great, ending a very interesting season that promises much for the future.
NEXT: Remembrance of the Daleks
Wednesday, 2 September 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
I'm surprised! With the exception of maybe eight stories, you've been mostly positive about the JNT era. Even McCoy's first season, which most people seem to despise due to its "panto" nature. Not that it's a bad thing of course. These are terrific reviews and completely valid viewpoints. Not to mention you are giving these a much more critical eye than I did, as a more or less indifferent viewer.
I've gotta disagree with you about this story, because the "panto" aspect really is a bit much. The scene in the milk bar where Ace quits is cringe-inducing, as is the sort-of-amusing but overwhelmingly silly philosophical exchange between the Doctor and the guard. Oh, and the very literal cliffhanger: what the HECK?! As you say, postmodern, but was it really necessary? It struck me as lazy or gratuitous.
But true, that scene where the face melts off is AWESOME. Oh, and, Mel leaves. Always a good thing.
I read another reviewer somewhere call this story "unfocused." That seems about right to me.
And excellent going! I feel like we might reach Tennant by Christmas!
Actually, I'm a fool who's bad at math, as you average about 13 stories a month, which would bring us to Tennant a few weeks before Christmas, unless something else happens. So yeah.
Post a Comment